Chopped Cheese: Nyc Bodega Culture & The Iconic Sandwich

Dylan Thuras: It’s a warm day in New York City. You are in search of a particular store that offers a very specific sandwich.

You stroll inside. The air conditioner is blasting, it is beautiful. And 2nd, you see that it is absolutely busy in right here. You have actually strolled into the center of the lunch rush. There are 10 customers packed all around you in this tiny shop, ordering sandwiches. And beyond that, there is one pervasive sound.

Jeremy: This is the New York that I grew up in, the colorful bodegas with the lights and the sweets and simply a variation of New york city that’s slowly obtaining modernized and gentrified. It happens. Points change. You can not anticipate some things to remain the very same permanently, so it is what it is.

Bodega Roots: A New York City Staple

Dylan: Jeremy’s store is kind of a tribute to the classic bodega. There’s a packed bodega feline resting on the counter. Jeremy states that that’s the supervisor.

Besides having actually matured above his family’s bodega, Anibal is also the collection manager at the Center for Puerto Rican Studies Library and Archives, or the Centro. He claims the earliest documented bodegas in the city started at some time around the 1920s, but a number of decades later on, bodega society absolutely took off.

Or you can strike up Jeremy at Bodega City, he has places in Brooklyn and in the Bronx. Or you can essentially simply walk right into any type of bodega on any type of block in New York City and state, “Offer me a chopped cheese,” and it will certainly be so great.

The sandwich absolutely came out of edge store society, yet in the previous years or so, it has actually spread out well beyond the bodega. It’s in Lincoln Facility, and of program, on the food selection is a cut cheese made with aged ribeye and truffles.

Chopped Cheese: From Bodega to Culinary Icon

Jeremy: It was an order that she messed up, I think it was. And she was like, “Yo, right here, just have this. It was one of my favored things.

I’m Dylan Thuras, and this is Atlas Obscura, a celebration of the world’s unusual, extraordinary, and fascinating areas. This episode was generated in partnership with New york city City Tourism. Today, we’re getting very close, and really individual, with a chopped cheese sandwich. It is a sandwich so fabled, you may also call it a type of a people sandwich. And we will certainly check out the bodega and delicatessens society that brought this brave sandwich to life.

Everybody was like, ooh, finding the sandwich. The sandwich struck a kind of chord. Media companies sent out reporters to make chopped cheese videos.

The Rise of Bodega Culture

Anibal: I would state that the moment duration where the bodega actually escalated to importance was from the ’40s to the ’70s. We saw a tenfold rise in the number of Puerto Ricans in New York City City. What was originally a community of around 60,000 in 1940 expanded to over 600,000 by 1980.

Dylan: So Jeremy took his experience growing up in a bodega and turned it into a new iteration, and a new version of the sliced cheese. When it comes to Anibal’s household, they offered their bodega when Anibal was about 10 years old.

Dylan: Today, the corner stores that are the forefathers of these really initial bodegas, they are all over. It can be tough to say a certain number, yet the quotes are someplace in between 7,000 and 14,000 delicatessens and bodegas across the city.

If you walk into the bodega and there is a whole pig roasting in the back, that’s a great bodega. Commonly, bodegas are Latino-owned, however every person we talked to for this episode claimed, you can say whatever you desire, deli, bodega, edge shop, you recognize when you see it. The sandwich definitely came out of edge store society, however in the past years or so, it has spread out well past the bodega. They are called Bodega Vehicle and Bodega City.

Some people would certainly get their mail delivered to the bodegas, especially if they were simply renting a solitary space in an apartment or condo or something like that. Lots of people did not have telephones, and the only place where you might make telephone call was to pay the bodeguero to utilize their phone. It was where you would trade gossip. That’s just how you would keep up to date on local happenings in your area. Someone died. A house’s vacant. Someone’s looking for work. It was likewise an engine of the informal economy, like a task bulletin board in its own means too.

Dylan: Anibal says there were a couple of reasons for this. Procedure Bootstrap has its own complex, debatable history, however essentially, it was a federal government program between Puerto Rico and the U.S., which was implied to transform Puerto Rico from a basically agrarian society into an industrialized one. It totally reshaped the island, and at some point, there were not adequate commercial work to go about, and so the Puerto Rican federal government developed an office particularly designed to push Puerto Rican migration to New York City.

Yes, you can get it anywhere in New York City, any bodega. You can go to any type of corner shop to get a chopped cheese, however I would constantly remix it. I would certainly always do something different with the cut cheese.

One tale goes that a cook was asked to make a Philly cheesesteak and improvised with the ingredients that they had on hand. One more says that a chef ran out of circular burger buns, so chopped up a cheeseburger to fit a hero roll rather. And yet an additional variation says that the cook– this is my favored– had oral problems, and he was just attempting to make a sandwich that was simpler to eat.

Chopped Cheese Origin Stories

There have been numerous, several heated internet discussions regarding this. You go down the rabbit opening if you want. It is so deep. But the debate of the sliced cheese apart, like with a great deal of food beginning tales, the genuine story is the abundant society and background that gave birth to this sandwich: The grocery store culture, which it originated from.

I indicate, it seems basic, I guess. It is sort of a cheeseburger, all chopped up. It seems like, what is there even to say? But I can not think of another sandwich out there that has become such an astounding social lightning arrester.

The Chopped Cheese’s Enduring Appeal

Bear in mind Jeremy, that attempted his initial cut cheese in his mama’s bodega when he was a young adult? Nowadays, he runs a food truck and two counter restaurants dedicated to the sandwich. They are called Bodega Truck and Bodega City.

Dylan: Cut cheese quickly ended up being a delicatessens and bodega staple. New York is a big area. And in reality, also just within the boroughs, the chopped cheese is kind of like a regional point.

In honor of New York City’s 400th anniversary in 2025 and the United States’s 250th in 2026, New York City Tourist has released Founded By New York City, a project that commemorates the 5 boroughs’s motivating accomplishments and legacy of groundbreaking innovation. Find ways to celebrate the city that’s constantly making history at foundedbynyc.com.

Anibal: I keep in mind definitely sitting on the deli refrigerator with my legs hanging there and simply considering all the people go and come. They were recognized for their sandwiches. This is like pre-chopped cheese. This bodega didn’t have a grill or anything like that, yet the thing that my grandpa was understood for was he would make pernil, so traditional Puerto Rican seasoned pork shoulder, like roasted pork shoulder, and they would heal their own Virginia porks and points like that and do things. For the holidays, they would roast an entire pig in the back of the bodega kitchen area, which was quite great.

If you walk into the bodega and there is a whole pig toasting in the back, that’s a good bodega. Commonly, bodegas are Latino-owned, but everyone we spoke to for this episode stated, you can state whatever you want, deli, bodega, corner shop, you understand when you see it. What is clear is that the initial bodegas come from with Puerto Rican immigration to New York City, people like Anibal’s ancestors.

Bodegas: More Than Just Stores

And after that you know what took place following. An Upper West Side dining establishment created an outright uproar when they prepared to market the sandwich for 15 dollars, a costly variation of the chopped cheese, a very potent symbol of gentrification.

Dylan: Listen, per their own. When it actually comes down to it, I guess I’m an egg and cheese guy. Anyway, Anibal states the chopped cheese is among these sandwiches that has gotten in that vaulted area. It is currently strongly considered what he calls a people sandwich.

The beginnings of sandwiches transform out to be exceptionally murky. Usually, people concur that this sandwich originated someplace uptown in some delicatessens, some bodega, at some time around the late ’90s, perhaps early 2000s.

Jeremy: No, believe me, there’s people that concern me regularly and resembles, “I resided in New York my entire life, and I’ve never ever had a cut cheese.” So it’s crazy that they pertain to me, and they’re like 40 years of ages, and they’re simply finding the sliced cheese.

Gentrifcation of NYC : Impact on Local Culture

Anibal: So you have this big post-World War II migration, and you have new Puerto Rican communities. They desire the food from their homelands, and the bodega was that center centerpiece, similar manner in which we depend on it now, the Puerto Rican neighborhoods, I would state, count on it extra so, and it served a greater social function than it does now.

Anibal: Whether that’s demographic modification, financial modification, social adjustment, you can depend on locating a bodega where you recognize you can get something to consume alcohol, you can obtain something respectable to eat at a fairly low-cost cost, and any type of arbitrary points that you might require for your apartment or condo, whether that’s batteries or a collection of headphones or last-minute presents, you can discover them in the bodega.

Chopped Cheese: a folk sandwich?

Generally, people concur that this sandwich originated somewhere classy in some delicatessens, some bodega, at some point around the late ’90s, possibly early 2000s.

This is what you have actually come below for, because this is the noise of a sliced cheese sandwich coming to life. Ground beef, thawed cheese, cut up on a flat-top grill.

You ‘d most likely just pass it by if you really did not recognize what you were looking for. It’s a delicatessens, something you would certainly find on, you know, basically every block in New York. This is not just any type of deli. This one is called Hajji’s, and it asserts to have actually developed the very sandwich that you look for.

Anibal: Every folk sandwich has its beginning story? The sliced cheese certainly– if it really did not happen in East Harlem, it would have taken place someplace.